
In the Portland Airport, I sat down at gate C7 and opened up my laptop. Across the aisle from me I noticed a guy with a trim red beard and a plaid wool shirt, working away on his laptop. A PC, I thought. Technically not on my team. (Which isn’t to say that I can’t have a PC user on my team, or that I’m SO brand loyal in general, but still.) As soon as we board, it turns out he sits down right beside me, and before we’ve left the airport, he’s asking me friendly questions about myself. Now, I am the kind of airplane traveler who doesn’t really like to talk to people while flying. I think people who talk to each other always end up sounding crazy, no matter what their conversation is. And of course, being the efficient multitasker workaholic that I am, I’ve already got plans for my activities on the plane; take aerial photographs for my art project, read Dan Savage’s new book, and so on. So of course, when the guy starts asking me where I’m headed, what I do in Portland, etc, I’m friendly, but really I just want to be taking pictures out the window of the plane. “Oh, what are you reading?” he asks, and I hand him the book, “The Commitment,” and tell him how funny I think Dan Savage is. Now, for some reason, even though I’ve already ascertained that the man is not on my computer team, I assume (from his shirt that looks just like my friend Calvin’s, from his beard that looks just like my friend Bryce’s) that he’s generally on my team. So I tell him how he writes a sex advice column, he’s written other books, he’s political, etc. You know, DAN SAVAGE. He’s looking at me a little bit blankly, but whatever. Then I happen to mention that the marriage he’s writing about in his book is a gay marriage. Just as the plane is taking off, while I am trying to be polite and get what I want at the same time, (poised with my camera at the window, ready to capture whatever cool patterns are created by the strangely designed suburbs below) he says, “let’s have a debate! What do you think about gay marriage?” uh, hold on, I’ll tell you in a second…
“Aw, man,” I think to myself as I wildly start shooting photos out the window, “now is my one chance to be well spoken.” And it was Dan Savage himself who asserted so clearly the need for us lefties to preach to the choir- to practice our arguments, to gather the information, to feel strong and certain about what we think is correct. I turn back to the guy, saying, “I think people should be able to marry each other if they want to make the commitment.” Yeah, but why? “Well,” I go on, and spout out some sort of jumbled but relatively organized stuff about tax breaks and health insurance. The more I say, the more I know, with a sinking feeling in my heart, that this nicely trimmed man sitting next to me is in no way on my team. Not on my computer team, not on my don’t-talk-to-strangers-on-airplanes team, and not on my gay marriage team. Eventually I get bored of my own points, and ask him what he thinks. He then begins talking to me about the history of marriage from 3000 BC, what the bible says, what Jesus would say. etc. (In my mind, I am thinking, wait, now what would Dan Savage say about this? He has something he would say about this. If only I’d been to the church of Dan Savage more than just that one night at Powell’s.) I do my best to listen. Even as my skin bristles. I try not to pick a fight. But as he goes on to say that kids in homes with gay people are brainwashed, no, brainwashed is too strong a word, how about conditioned, I just can’t keep my lefty-opinionated, kindergarten-teaching, critical-thinking mouth shut. I believe people can think for themselves, I say. No, I don’t think it’s a “gay lifestyle.” I don’t think it’s a “choice.” And I certainly don’t think that same sex parenting teams are abusing their kids, or making them gay for that matter, just by existing. As we speak back and forth, I notice the people in front of us whispering to each other, and I swear I see the woman peek through the seats to see who the crazy girl is behind her. But lunatic that I am, I still have to emphasize that I think people can and should be able to make their own decisions about their lives. A right-wing Christian should be able to choose not to be in a gay relationship, even if it goes against their own sexual orientation. But I don’t think they should be able to decide how other people carry on their relationships. It’s none of their business. Now, I believe my own beliefs, and strongly, but for some reason I felt stretched and challenged on this day to really consider a different view. This was because I wanted to be respected by this guy, maybe even have my ideas be considered by him, and I was wishing that the people in front of me were thinking I was intelligent, not crazy. What it all came down to was a debate within myself, and had nothing to do with the wool shirt beard guy. Somehow I thought our varying beliefs should be able to coexist. But however I spun it, it kept ending up that if this guy got his way, (gay people vanish off the face of the earth) my perfect world would be destroyed, and if I got my way (all people have equal rights and are respected) his perfect world would be destroyed.
My brain was swimming with my internal questions, and awkwardly, but not in an unfriendly way, I stopped talking to my Christian neighbor. “The Commitment” was burning a hole in the seat pocket in front of me. There was still an hour of flight time. I wanted to read that book so bad. But what seemed like candy to me 30 minutes ago now seemed very much like X rated porn. I didn’t care. I wanted to read my book. Besides, It’s going to be overdue by the time I get home, I have to finish it in the next three days, or I pay. I opened the book.